Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Evidential

created by Webster 1913

(idea) by Gritchka (2.5 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Thu Feb 19 2004 at 23:22:10

An evidential marker is a grammatical indication of what evidence a speaker has for what they say. In English we resort to roundabout ways of showing this, such as 'they say' or 'should be' or 'is supposed to be' for things we've heard, but in some languages the marking is an obligatory part of grammar, just as English has to mark present tense or past tense.

For example, in Quechua Paymi runasimita riman and Paysi runasimita riman both mean 'S/he speaks Quechua'. The difference is that the -mi suffix shows that I know this from personal experience, whereas -si means I know this because I learnt it from someone else. There is a third evidential marker, -cha, which indicates uncertainty: Paycha runasimita riman means 'S/he probably speaks Quechua'.

It is important not to be led astray by the lack of this feature in English. The two former sentences both mean 'S/he speaks Quechua'. It would be exaggerating the difference to translate one as 'I know s/he speaks Quechua' and the other as 'I heard s/he speaks Quechua'. When you're saying these in Quechua you're not saying you know anything or you've heard anything, you're simply stating a fact about the person: they speak Quechua. There's no particular reason to suppose the hearsay -si form is in any way uncertain. After all, there's the -cha form to indicate actual uncertainty.

Translating them into English with extra bits to show up the difference runs afoul of pragmatics as expressed in Grice's maxims. The simplest thing to say is just 'she speaks Quechua', so if you use extra words and say 'I've heard she speaks Quechua', that pragmatically implies you couldn't just say 'she speaks Quechua'. And why, thinks your hearer, couldn't you say this? Probably because you weren't really sure: well, I've heard she does, but... So it's important to stress that the evidential marker in Quechua is just a grammatically necessary choice. It does not contain anything corresponding to 'so I've heard' or 'they say' or 'I'm not sure'.

Tibetan has verbs 'to be' that distinguish personal knowledge and hearsay. Turkish has a suffix -miş that indicates hearsay, but can also be used for related evidential purposes: even if the speaker and the hearer can see the fact, it might indicate surprise, as in English if George turns up unexpectedly you might say to him, 'Well, it seems George is here.'

The Californian language Wintu has a particularly rich battery of evidential grammar, as do a lot of American languages. In Wintu the unmarked form is for direct visual experience. For sensory experience that's non-visual, and for inference from intuition, they use the suffix -nthEr. For inference from observed results use -ree, for inference from previous experience use -?el, and for hearsay evidence use -kee.

In Kashaya, another Californian language, a conversation might open with a speaker using the -wela form, meaning they're doing the action or they've just been doing it. It then moves into the -wa form, which is for ordinary factuals.

Kiefer, F., 'Morphology and Pragmatics', in Spencer and Zwicky (eds), 1998, The Handbook of Morphology, Blackwell
Coronel-Molina, S., 1989, Quechua Phrasebook, Lonely Planet


(definition) by Webster 1913 (print) Tue Dec 21 1999 at 23:30:43

Ev`i*den"tial (?), a.

Relating to, or affording, evidence; indicative; especially, relating to the evidences of Christianity.

Bp. Fleetwood. "Evidential tracks." Earle.. -- Ev`i*den"tial*ly, adv.

 

© Webster 1913.


printable version
chaos

pragmatics Evidentiary Inference Women in Love
Intuition Evidence King Arthur Uncertainty
hearsay Quechua Tibetan Gricean maxims
Factual
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Nodes your cousin would have liked:
Heroin, MPTP, and the key to Parkinson's Disease
Sand crab
A man with a tapeworm up his nose
The gods
Hermetic
Some gifts are so fleeting
Turkana Boy
Creating a bad homepage
I like monkeys
Tea tree oil
Body language
what all the kids are reading
Anglo-Saxon Laws and Customs
New Writeups
The Jacket
Words of Advice(idea)
keepinitreal
Why buy the cow when you can get the milk for free?(idea)
John_Fox
Good Intentions Gone Wrong(person)
Cuckowski
Slavonic Princess(poetry)
Heitah
Posthumous Oscar(thing)
ignis_glaciesque
University of South Florida(place)
ignis_glaciesque
Flogstaskriket(idea)
liveforever
Caesar's last breath(idea)
dagnyswaggart
she wants to believe(personal)
antigravpussy
he doesn't know, but her eyes widen too far(thing)
dagnyswaggart
Wild tides guard her secrets(poetry)
Lord Brawl
Caesar's last breath(poetry)
locke baron
Forgotten things in space(fiction)
sitaraika
Colours(idea)
etouffee
Wild tides guard her secrets(poetry)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company